The Best and Worst of 2017

2017 saw an uptick in films compared to the previous year, but it was hardly stellar.  Having no films that I could rate a 9 is disappointing.  2013 and 2014 spoiled me I reckon.  *Asterisk denotes films I saw at home via VOD.

It Comes at Night — 3/10 and Honours for Worst Movie of the Year

Personal Shopper — 4/10

Logan — 4/10

Jigsaw — 4/10

Blade Runner 2049 — 4/10

The Square — 4/10

Dunkirk — 5/10

Raw — 5/10

Good Time — 5/10

Last Flag Flying — 5/10

The Book of Henry — 5/10

Wonder Wheel — 5/10

Life — 5/10

Logan Lucky — 5/10

Three Billboards blah blah — 5/10

Split — 5/10

Norman — 6/10

T2 Trainspotting — 6/10

Wind River — 6/10

Colossal — 6/10

Brigsby Bear* — 6/10

Lucky — 6/10

Battle of the Sexes — 6/10

Happy Death Day — 6/10

Thor: Ragnarok — 6/10

Wonder Woman — 6/10

Call Me by Your Name — 6/10

Patti Cake$ — 6/10

Lady Bird — 6/10

War for the Planet of the Apes — 7/10

A Ghost Story* — 7/10

It — 7/10

Sleight — 7/10

The Post — 7/10

The Big Sick — 7/10

The Beguiled — 7/10

Lost in Paris — 7/10

The Shape of Water — 7/10

Baby Driver — 7/10

Mother! — 7/10

== TOP TEN ==

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

NOTE: All in Top Ten are rated 8/10

10. The Disaster Artist

9. The Little Hours I’m upgrading from my original score.  Best comedy of the year — this one grew on me.

8. Lady Macbeth

4. The Florida Project (Not the best of the year, but probably my favorite), ThelmaThe Killing of a Sacred Deer, and Ingrid Goes West are four in fourth.

3. Phantom Thread

1. Get Out and I, Tonya — Clearly the Best Movies of the Year.  I can’t call one over the other.

End Note: What would my year-end list be without an end note?  In this case, I just wanted to point out that there is not a large delta between number 1 and number 10 above, hence the ties.  All are very good and worthwhile films, so watch a trailer or two and decide which one’s for you.

* * *

End Note #2: This year there were a lot of repeats in movie titles: Wonder, Wonder Woman, and Wonder Wheel; Lucky and Logan Lucky, Lady Bird and Lady Macbeth.  To stretch the idea out, you could throw in It and It Comes at Night.  And if It had been the It that came at night, It Comes at Night might well have been a whole lot better.

Advertisements

VOD Log: Brigsby Bear

Early parts of Brigsby Bear looked like a badly-executed, very narrow corollary to Room — and I was thinking it headed for contention as worst of the year.  Soon enough, however, Brigsby Bear turns into a sweetly endearing and entertaining film.  There’s still too much suspension of belief required, but the movie doesn’t let you dwell on it — which is the same that could be said about the missing titles.

Brigsby Bear was yet another barely-shown yet marketed film.  In this case, it wasn’t a whole lot to miss — but that’s beside the point.  This will be the last one before my 2017 list; the remaining two are A Cure for Wellness and The Blackcoat’s Daughter.  I’ll let you know if I ever get round to watching those.

A nice surprise-bonus of Brigsby Bear: Mark Hamill is a good actor!  6/10

Comparison Notes: Recommended: The Wolfpack, The Disaster Artist, Short Term 12, Sling Blade, Superbad, Butter; Not Recommended: The Book of Henry, Captain Fantastic, Life is Beautiful

VOD Log: A Ghost Story

I’ll start with a side note.  I saw the trailer for A Ghost Story about three times, I think two of which were at an AMC.  And then the local AMCs collectively failed to ever show the film, or if they did it was for no more than a week or a day.  When it was still showing in theaters outside my area, e.g. in LA, I went to one of the main AMCs to watch another film and was surprised to see a super-sized lobby cardboard poster display for the film.  I inquired about it, and was told there were no plans to show the film.

A theater showing trailers and setting large promotional items on display for a movie seems only to make sense if said theater will at some point show the movie.  But that’s indicative of numerous areas of mismanagement on the part of AMC.  I went to a film lately and a couple of the seats had such a strong fecal odor I moved.

* * *

I point out the AMC nonsense above because I felt like A Ghost Story, starring consummate actors Casey Affleck and Rooney Mara, was one of the more significant indies of the year, and given short shrift by the cinemas.  Nonetheless, I was determined to watch it to consider among the films of 2017, so I did something that is rare for me these days: saw it at home.

The movie is intriguing, and certainly compelling — but falls short of providing that grand a-ha moment.  In other words, I liked it despite a thin story.  7/10

* * *

Note: This film is presented in a square (1.33:1) frame with rounded corners, for no particularly obvious or excellent reason.  An affectation, perhaps, but in this case it does not distract from the movie — unlike in American Honey.  I like a lot that A24 Films does, but the square frame trend I hope can be put to rest.

Comparison Notes: Recommended: To The Wonder; Not Recommended: Ain’t Them Bodies Saints (previous project with Affleck and Mara)

Wound Around a Phantom Thread

I still don’t know what Paul Thomas Anderson was thinking with Inherent Vice.  As I wrote at the time, that film was so out of character for PT Anderson as to be unrecognizable.  Phantom Thread represents, at least relatively speaking, a return to form.  I say relatively speaking, because unlike his past projects, I doubt that this film will stick with me over the years so strongly — but only time will tell I suppose.  The edginess of his earlier cinematic style seems missing, or at least transformed.

Still, Phantom Thread is a strong and lovely picture.  The RT consensus:

Phantom Thread‘s finely woven narrative is filled out nicely by humor, intoxicating romantic tension, and yet another impressively committed performance from Daniel Day-Lewis.

Day-Lewis’s foil, his co-star, was fantastic as well.  Katie Walsh:

Paul Thomas Anderson’s enigmatic romance “Phantom Thread” is a mystery. Not of the murder kind, but of the heart, posing questions of love, power and submission. The mystery? Who’s in control?

If you go in expecting a Daniel Day-Lewis movie, you’ll walk away with a Vicky Krieps movie, and we’re all the better for it. The Luxembourgian actress will sweep you off your feet.

Peter Travers:

It’s endlessly fascinating to watch the actor and artist behind the camera (sharers in the same creative obsession) negotiate a hard truce between art and life. Anderson is deliberate and cunning about revealing the secrets he’s sewn into the fabric of his spellbinder of a film. Taking full measure of Phantom Thread may require more than one viewing – a challenge any genuine movie lover will be eager to accept. Our advice for now: just sit back and behold.

Looking over all these reviews makes me think the film may stick with me more so than I am now thinking.  Certainly, the performances are absolutely riveting — perhaps more so than any picture of the last year.  For now, considered among the films of 2017: about on par with Lady Macbeth.  8/10

Comparison Notes (all recommended): Mother!, Punch-Drunk Love, Rebecca

I, Tonya Will Kick Your Ass. Literally.

Sometimes it takes a true story to make the best movie of the year.  This is one of those times.  The first half absolutely soars.  Once the movie shifts to “the incident,” it gets a little off track and bogs down, but is redeemed by the end.

I, Tonya opens with the following blurb:

Based on irony-free, wildly contradictory, totally true interviews with Tonya Harding and Jeff Gillooly

Like a Michener account, and the disclaimer above speaks to this, there is a sense that is not necessarily the verbatim truth of everything exactly the way it happened — but boy it sure feels like it is.  It really puts you there — and it’s highly compelling.

Propelling I, Tonya is a glorious tour de force by Margot Robbie — clearly the best female performance of the year.  Allison Janney as her mother is utter perfection as well.  Both should be winning Oscars on March 4th — but sadly won’t.

With the Winter Olympics next month, the timing could not be better.  You’ll definitely come away with an understanding of the tricky triple axel that you didn’t have before.  And one final note: make sure to stay for the end credits.

Best of the year, but shy of a ‘perfect 9’.  8/10